Some of the most valuable opportunities in my career started as additional work. That doesn’t mean saying yes to everything is always the right answer.
One of the most important transitions in my career started when someone else left.
I was working in finance at the University of Toledo when our Treasury Manager accepted a position outside the university. Rather than replace him, the university redistributed his responsibilities.
I was given responsibility for daily cash positioning and management of a fixed-income portfolio that could fluctuate from roughly $25 million to more than $100 million.
I understood the basics of fixed-income investing, but mostly from an academic perspective. Actually managing an institutional portfolio was different.
I had to understand the university’s cash and revenue cycle. When did money come in? When did it go out? How much liquidity did we need to maintain? How far out could we reasonably invest?
There wasn’t a detailed roadmap.
For the most part, I was told to figure it out.
One Responsibility Leads to Another
Once I started digging into the portfolio, one of my first questions was why we weren’t doing more to maximize our investment opportunities.
As a public institution, we were limited in what we could invest in. But limited didn’t mean there weren’t opportunities.
The university had a fairly predictable cash cycle. By understanding that cycle, we could ladder eligible fixed-income investments and Treasury securities across different maturities while still maintaining the liquidity necessary to meet our operating needs.
It worked.
And success in that responsibility started opening other doors.
I became involved in financing projects and got my first exposure to a university bond issuance. I wasn’t leading the financing, but I was given responsibility for investing the bond proceeds, which meant balancing return with liquidity based on anticipated construction draws.
It was another thing I hadn’t done before.
So I figured it out.
My boss at the time, the university’s Associate Vice President for Finance, began relying on me more for specific projects and financial analysis. Eventually, one of those projects took me well outside treasury.
A Problem in Athletics
The university’s athletic department had been running annual deficits that could range from roughly $1 million to $2.5 million. By 2007, the accumulated deficit had grown to more than $16 million.
I was asked to help evaluate the operation and determine what it actually cost to run the department.
The objective wasn’t simply to tell athletics to spend less. We needed to understand the minimum operating budget necessary to run the program on a year-to-year basis.
The review ultimately resulted in an approximately $3 million increase in the department’s annual budget.
But additional money wasn’t going to solve the entire problem.
The university also concluded that athletics needed stronger financial leadership inside the department to monitor the budget and strengthen financial controls.
Then came a conversation I completely misunderstood.
The CFO and university president suggested moving me into athletics.
I was offended.
I thought they must not believe I was doing a very good job in treasury.
I had taken on increasingly significant responsibilities, worked hard to develop my knowledge of treasury and believed I was building a future for myself in that area. Being asked to leave it didn’t initially feel like an opportunity.
After a much longer conversation, I realized it was almost exactly the opposite.
They believed my success and work ethic made me someone they could trust with a difficult assignment. But there was something else they believed I could bring to the position.
I could communicate with people.
Athletics wasn’t primarily populated by accountants and finance professionals. It was populated by coaches, administrators and staff whose expertise was athletics.
The university needed someone who could understand the financial side of the operation while also translating that information into language that made sense to people whose primary responsibility wasn’t finance.
Just as importantly, I needed to understand their operational needs well enough that finance wasn’t simply the office telling them what they couldn’t do.
Once I understood why I was being asked, the decision looked different.
I wasn’t prepared to leave the university. I was loyal to the institution and appreciated the opportunities I’d already been given. If its leadership believed I could make an impact in an area that needed help, I thought it was worth trying.
So I said yes.
The Job Didn’t Stay the Same for Long
Initially, my responsibilities were fairly straightforward.
I had budgetary authority, reviewed and approved transactions and began realigning departmental budgets around the university’s newly established funding level.
Then, almost as soon as that new allocation was established, the university went through a mid-year budget reduction.
It was an early lesson in something that would become familiar throughout my career:
The budget you’re given isn’t necessarily the budget you’re going to manage.
But the position continued to evolve far beyond budgeting.
About two years into my time in athletics, our marketing director wanted to step away from responsibility for the department’s retail operation. It had only been intended as a temporary part of her job, and we didn’t have the resources to hire a full-time retail manager.
I could see that the operation needed attention.
So I agreed to take it on.
I didn’t just establish the accounting. I remodeled and rebranded the store, changed the merchandise mix, developed new vendor relationships and established a new ordering cycle. I became heavily involved in merchandise selection and design and changed the way we sold merchandise at games.
And I was doing it with the help of a graduate assistant rather than a full-time retail staff member.
Over the next four years, retail sales grew by more than 20% annually, eventually reaching approximately $650,000 a year.
As the operation grew, I started exploring the possibility of opening a location in a local mall. After looking more closely at what would be involved, I decided we should put the idea on hold.
Then I mentioned that to the Director of Athletics.
He told me he had already discussed the idea with the university president, and she was excited about having a presence in the mall.
I took that as a pretty good indication that putting it on hold was no longer the preferred option.
Eleven days later, we were open.
In that time, I signed the lease, oversaw the painting and remodeling, merchandised the store and got the operation up and running.
And retail was still only one part of my job.
When Saying Yes Keeps Working
During those years, we were constantly looking for new revenue opportunities.
We introduced alcohol sales at our venues. We expanded retail. We worked on concessions, sponsorship opportunities and other ways to improve the financial performance of the department.
Eventually, I started looking at our arena itself.
Savage Arena had historically hosted concerts, but that business had largely disappeared after a new downtown arena opened in Toledo. Major concert promoters had preferred venues and routing relationships, and ours wasn’t one of them.
I knew very little about concert promotion.
So I started learning.
I talked with people who had been involved with concerts at the university in the past, brought in an outside resource who understood the industry and worked with our legal department as we tried to figure out how to bring concerts back to campus.
It took almost two years of working on offers before we finally decided to take a chance on independent promotion and created a multi-event concert series at Savage Arena.
The first two events were extremely successful, and the series ultimately generated more than $300,000 in unbudgeted net revenue.
The third event wasn’t going to be.
Ticket sales weren’t developing the way we needed them to, and I made the decision to cancel the show. It cost us approximately $75,000.
That wasn’t a small amount of money.
But going forward with a show that wasn’t selling simply because we’d already invested money in it could have cost considerably more.
Sometimes the best financial decision is accepting the loss you already have rather than turning it into a bigger one.
The Opportunity I Turned Down
Somewhere in the middle of all of this, treasury came back into the picture.
The person who had followed me as Assistant Treasurer and eventually became Treasurer retired. He and I had different strengths. He was particularly strong on the investment side. My strengths were more heavily concentrated in treasury accounting, cash management and debt.
When the university had difficulty filling the Treasurer position, the AVP reached out and offered it to me.
The position would have come with roughly a 40% increase over what I was making in athletics.
And I turned it down.
Two years earlier, I had initially been offended when university leadership asked me to leave treasury.
Now I was being offered the opportunity to go back, with the title and compensation that would have made the decision pretty easy to justify.
But something had changed.
I had invested myself in athletics. There were projects I wanted to see through, problems I still wanted to solve and opportunities I wanted to pursue.
So I chose the work and the challenge over the salary.
When the Person Becomes the Workaround
Looking back, I’m glad I took those opportunities.
I learned things I never would have learned by staying strictly inside a finance job description.
I learned treasury by doing it. I learned how to communicate financial information to people who weren’t finance professionals. I learned retail operations, merchandising, revenue generation, contract negotiation, venue economics and concert promotion.
But there’s another side to that story that I understand much better today.
Every time I successfully absorbed another responsibility, it became easier for another responsibility to be added.
The retail operation didn’t suddenly have more resources because I agreed to manage it. We still didn’t have a full-time retail manager. I simply figured out how to make it work.
The same pattern repeated itself in other areas.
And when you’re in the middle of it, success can make the arrangement look sustainable.
The store is growing. The new location opens. The event happens. Revenue is generated. Problems get solved.
From the outside, it works.
But sometimes the person who keeps figuring it out becomes the workaround.
That’s something I didn’t fully appreciate at the time.
Looking Back
After my time in athletics, the position was refocused on the core financial and budget responsibilities that had originally brought me into the department. Retail was outsourced, and the concert series didn’t continue.
Seeing those pieces separated made me realize how far the role had grown beyond the job I’d originally accepted.
That doesn’t mean I regret taking on those responsibilities.
I don’t.
Some of the most interesting and valuable experiences of my career happened precisely because I was willing to step outside my job description and say, I’ll figure it out.
One responsibility created the opportunity for the next one.
But experience has also taught me that there’s a difference between stretching yourself into an opportunity and continually absorbing responsibilities without the resources necessary to support them.
Early in my career, I probably thought proving your value meant being the person who could always figure out how to make it work.
Today, I think proving your value also means recognizing when the organization needs to address the underlying resource problem rather than relying on one person to keep solving it.
I’d also ask some questions I didn’t ask often enough then.
What resources come with the responsibility?
What, if anything, comes off my plate?
Is this temporary or permanent?
And if it succeeds, who is eventually going to own it?
Those questions wouldn’t necessarily change my answer.
So would I still say yes?
Absolutely.
I’d just ask a few more questions before I did.
-
Sometimes the Opportunity Isn’t in the Job Description
Some of the most valuable opportunities in my career started as additional work. That doesn’t…
-
Internal Controls Work—Until the Workaround Becomes the Process
What happens when internal controls meet operational reality? A look at how resource constraints, workarounds…
-
Hello, World – From the Other Side of the Job Market
A perspective on navigating today’s job market — from intense competition and changing technology to…

Leave a Reply